In the house

Is carmine (E120) halal?

Updated 9 November 2026

Carmine is made from crushed cochineal insects, not from beets, hibiscus, or a lab-made dye, whatever a rosy pink yogurt or a red candy shell might suggest. It's also listed as E120, cochineal extract, or natural red 4, and for many scholars the question is its source, an extract of an insect, although some argue that processing changes the ruling.

Where carmine comes from

Carmine comes from the cochineal, a small scale insect that lives on prickly pear cacti, mostly farmed in Peru and the Canary Islands. The insects are dried and crushed, and a red pigment called carminic acid is extracted from their bodies. That pigment becomes carmine. It has been used as a dye for centuries, long before synthetic reds existed, and it is still prized because it is genuinely stable and vivid compared to many plant-based alternatives.

None of that is in dispute. What matters for a halal determination is a much narrower question: is an insect other than a locust something a Muslim may eat or use as an ingredient at all.

Why insects are the sticking point

Locusts have a clear, well-established exception in the Islamic legal tradition. Beyond that, the classical schools diverge sharply on land-dwelling insects and creeping creatures in general, and carmine sits squarely inside that older disagreement rather than being a new question on its own.

The majority view

Many scholars in the Hanafi, Shafi'i and Hanbali schools hold that insects other than locusts may not be eaten, and some apply that to an extract of the insect's body such as carmine. Published fatwas do not all agree. Darul Ifta Birmingham, a Hanafi body, says that carmine from cochineal insects is not permissible. A fatwa.org.au answer (Mufti Faizal Riza, 2011) notes that some scholars argue the extraction transforms the dye (istihala), rejects that argument, and rules that food containing E120 is not permissible. SeekersGuidance rules food use not permissible and external use permissible, because it treats the processed colour as pure. We found no published statement on carmine from IFANCA, so do not assume its position. Malaysia's National Fatwa Committee is reported to have ruled cochineal colouring permissible with conditions, but we could not open the JAKIM e-fatwa portal to confirm the wording, so check it there.

A minority view

A minority of bodies permit it. The Indonesian Ulema Council (MUI), in Fatwa No. 33 of 2011, ruled that food and drink colouring from cochineal is halal provided it is beneficial and not harmful, reasoning by comparison with the locust after consulting experts. Egypt's Dar al-Ifta permits carminic acid as a colorant because extraction transforms it (istihala). This is a genuine, live difference of opinion rather than a fringe curiosity, and Muslims who follow these bodies are not stepping outside recognized scholarship. The permissive view is not simply a Maliki one: Darul Ifta Birmingham says the Maliki view also forbids carmine. If you are unsure which view applies to you, asking a local scholar familiar with your school of thought is more useful than trying to settle it from a label alone.

Where carmine actually shows up

It hides in more places than most people expect, partly because "natural color" on a label can mean almost anything.

Labeling rules vary by country. In the United States, carmine and cochineal extract must be named specifically rather than folded into a vague "artificial color" or "natural color" line, which actually makes it easier to spot once you know what to look for. The rule has applied since 2011 under FDA's colour labelling regulation. In other markets it may only appear as E120, or sometimes just as "color" with no further detail at all.

How to check a specific product

The practical habit is simple: read past "natural flavor" and "natural color" and look for the actual name, E120, carmine, cochineal, or carminic acid. A halal certification mark helps, because the certifier decides which ingredients it accepts, but ask it or the scholar you follow how they treat carmine rather than assuming. For anything uncertified, the halal ingredient checker is a faster way to catch E-numbers like this one than trying to memorize them.

If you are trying to build a household habit around this rather than checking one product at a time, keep a short list of the names for carmine: E120, cochineal extract, carminic acid, natural red 4 and, in cosmetics, CI 75470. Crimson lake is a pigment made from carmine. Not every red is carmine, though. Pigment Red 4 (CI 12085) is a synthetic dye with nothing to do with the insect, so do not reject a product on that name alone.

What this comes down to

What is settled is the underlying question: whether insects other than locusts may be eaten is a long-standing difference between the schools, not something invented for modern food labels. Individual fatwas still diverge on extracts, as the answers above show, so where you land depends on the scholar you follow. Ask someone qualified rather than relying on a food label alone.

Carmine in lipstick and other cosmetics

In cosmetics carmine is listed as CI 75470, also called carmine or natural red 4. In food it is E120. They are the same dye. Other reds are different substances: CI 15850, for example, is a synthetic pigment, and CI 12085 is Pigment Red 4, also synthetic. SeekersGuidance, linked above, rules food use not permissible and external use permissible. An AskImam answer (Darul Iftaa, checked by Mufti Ebrahim Desai) rules lipstick with carmine not permissible because it is ingested, but allows eye shadow and eyeliner. Ask the scholar you follow. If you would rather avoid carmine, look for CI 75470, carmine and cochineal on the ingredient list.

General information, not a fatwa. Where scholars differ, we try to say so. For your situation, ask a scholar you trust.